8 Movie Reboots & Remakes That Completely Missed The Point Of The Original

Summary

• Remakes often miss the essence of the original film, risking disappointment among audiences and failing to add anything new.
• Iconic movies are remade for modern audiences, but the pressure to live up to the original is immense, requiring unique elements.
• Live-action remakes of animated films must balance audience expectations with creative vision.

SCREENRANT VIDEO OF THE DAY

SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT

You are watching: 8 Movie Reboots & Remakes That Completely Missed The Point Of The Original

It’s often the worst movie remakes that completely miss the point of the original film. One of the main reasons a movie is remade is because the original is so iconic and well-loved by audiences. This success indicates to studios and filmmakers that there’s money to be made in creating a new version of the film with elements of the modern era. However, this also puts enormous pressure on the remake to not only live up to the original but bring something unique to the table that justifies the existence of the project.

Today, live-action versions of animated movies are popular examples of reboots that have performed well at the box office.

Occasionally, a story will be adapted and retold many times, like a fairytale or a folk legend. The audience’s baseline understanding of these stories opens the door for creatives to experiment. Today, live-action versions of animated movies are popular examples of reboots that have performed well at the box office. Greta Gerwig’s Chronicles of Narnia reboot exists within this legacy and has much riding on it after Gerwig’s strong reimagining of Little Women. Filmmakers like Gerwig are up to the task of taking on high-pressure IP that can divide audiences, but not all writers and directors have the same skills.

Related
9 Worst Sci-Fi Movie Remakes, Ranked

Beloved sci-fi films are frequently reimagined in Hollywood, but some remakes turn out worse than the originals, proving some should remain untouched.

8 Psycho (1998)

Original: Pyscho (1960)

Close

It’s safe to say that there’s never any reason to try and reboot an Alfred Hitchcock movie.

It’s safe to say that there’s never any reason to try and reboot an Alfred Hitchcock movie. Whatever an up-and-coming filmmaker thinks they have to add or update in his work, it’s likely that they’re wrong and are going to fall short of the iconic legacy left behind by Hitchcock. This happened to Gus Van Sant in 1998 with his version of Psycho, which stars Vince Vaughn in a terrible recreation of the character Norman Bates. Alongside Vaughn is a litany of A-list stars of the 1990s who decided to take a chance on this unfortunate remake.

Psycho is available to rent on Prime Video, Apple TV, or YouTube.

The additions Van Sant made to differentiate his remarkably similar take on the story were the inclusion of more graphic violence and the contemporary setting of the 1990s. However, something Hitchcock understood was that sometimes stakes and tension are at their height when aspects of the plot are left up to the audience’s imagination. Whatever Van Sant intended to achieve with his remake was lost in a project that didn’t understand itself or its predecessor.

Psycho (1998)
R
Mystery
Thriller
Horror

Psycho (1998) is a shot-for-shot remake of Alfred Hitchcock’s 1960 classic, directed by Gus Van Sant. Featuring Vince Vaughn as Norman Bates and Anne Heche as Marion Crane, the film revisits the chilling story of a young woman on the run who checks into a secluded motel managed by a mysterious proprietor. The cast also includes Julianne Moore and Viggo Mortensen in pivotal roles.

Director Gus Van Sant Release Date December 4, 1998 Cast Vince Vaughn , Anne Heche , Julianne Moore , Viggo Mortensen , William H. Macy Runtime 105 Minutes

7 Ghost In The Shell (2017)

Original: Ghost in the Shell (1995)

Close

Audiences who made it through the movie might have appreciated the strong visuals the project’s large budget afforded it.

When Scarlett Johansson was cast as the lead character in the live-action American Ghost in the Shell, it was a clear sign that the movie was destined to fail on all counts. Whitewashing a movie that’s so rooted in Japanese culture and representation was a massive failure on the part of the film and was a large part of why people refused to see the film. Audiences who made it through the movie might have appreciated the strong visuals the project’s large budget afforded it. Unfortunately, this couldn’t make up for the emptiness at the core of the glittering spectacle.

It’s no easy feat to adapt anime to live-action. The worst live-action anime adaptations all fail to translate the aesthetics and tone that soar in the animated versions. Though on paper, the 1995 Ghost in the Shell is just as emotionally removed and technologically oriented as the 2017 version, that’s not the case at all when analyzing the works. It’s far easier to relate to and empathize with Motoko in the animated iteration, and her journey is extremely emotional for the viewer.

Ghost in the Shell
PG-13
Drama
Action
Sci-Fi

Where to Watch

*Availability in US

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

Based on the internationally-acclaimed anime/manga “GHOST IN THE SHELL, ” a sci-fi action movie that follows the Major, a special ops, one-of-a-kind human-cyborg hybrid, who leads the elite task force Section 9. Devoted to stopping the most dangerous criminals and extremists, Section 9 faces an enemy whose singular goal is to wipe out Hanka Robotic’s advancements in cyber technology.

Director Rupert Sanders Release Date March 31, 2017 Cast Chin Han , Michael Pitt , Juliette Binoche , Rila Fukushima , Scarlett Johansson , Pilou Asbæk Runtime 107 Minutes Budget 110 million

6 Robin Hood (2018)

Original: The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938)

Close

There have been more film and television adaptations of Robin Hood and his legend than almost any other story. However, audiences must look back to 1938 to find a movie that fully does the character and heart of the tale justice.The Adventures of Robin Hood stars Errol Flynn, the epitome of a classic movie star. Charming, handsome, and the perfect Robin Hood inside and out. Others have come close to the 1938 film’s strength with decent adaptations, but the 2018 Robin Hood with Taron Egerton does not belong on that list.

Updated visual effects and brutally violent action sequences aren’t elements that would elevate any Robin Hood movie.

See more : Kanye West Ethnicity, What is Kanye West’s Ethnicity?

Perhaps the only true similarity between the character Egerton plays and the legendary Robin Hood is that they both use a bow and arrow. Egerton and the movie are clunky, disjointed, and fail to understand the purpose of telling a Robin Hood story. There should be joy, life, laughter, and color woven throughout the tale. The 2018 Robin Hood is more easily compared to the origin story of Batman than that of Robin of Loxley. Updated visual effects and brutally violent action sequences aren’t elements that would elevate any Robin Hood movie.

Robin Hood
PG-13
Action
Adventure

Where to Watch

*Availability in US

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

A retelling of the legend of Robin Hood, the 2018 film stars Taron Egerton as the English folk hero. Egerton’s Robin Hood is trained by Little John (Jamie Foxx) and fights in secret against the corrupt rule of the Sherriff of Nottingham (Ben Mendelsohn). Jamie Dornan, Tim Minchin, Eve Hewson, Paul Anderson, and F. Murray Abraham also appear in supporting roles.

Director Otto Barthurst Release Date November 21, 2018 Cast Paul Anderson , Tim Minchin , Taron Egerton , Eve Hewson , Josh Herdman , Ben Mendelsohn , Jamie Dornan , Jamie Foxx , Ian Peck , Björn Bengtsson Runtime 1h 56m Budget 100 million

5 Ben-Hur (2016)

Original: Ben-Hur (1959)

Close

As one of the best biblical epics of all time, the 1959 Ben-Hur truly earns the title. At almost three and a half hours long, watching the movie is a commitment, but it’s well worth it thanks to the amazing elements of the story, incredible practical sets, and historical costuming. Though not the first adaptation of the Ben-Hur story, the 1959 iteration is considered the definitive version and is cited as the work that will go down in history. It’s hard to know why the studio behind the 2016 Ben-Hur thought the film needed an update.

What remaking Ben-Hur achieved is a legacy opposite to that of the original. None of the actors live up to their roles, and it’s difficult to believe that any of them truly embody their characters. Like many remakes of its ilk, Ben-Hur fails to capture the spirit and has no reason for existing. The era of thrilling epics from the Hollywood Golden Age is a period gone by, and no number of reboots is going to bring it back. Even if Ben-Hur had been a box office and critical success, it would still lack the poignancy of the works that came before.

Ben-Hur
PG-13
Drama
History
Adventure

Where to Watch

*Availability in US

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

Ben-Hur is an action epic that retells the story of Judah Ben Hur, a prince falsely accused of treason by his adopted brother and best friend. Now, stripped of his title and separated from his family, Judah spends years at sea enslaved by the Romans. Despite his predicament, Judah will return to his homeland to seek revenge – but instead, may find redemption.

Director Timur Bekmambetov Release Date April 19, 2016 Cast Jack Huston , Toby Kebbell , Rodrigo Santoro , Morgan Freeman , Nazanin Boniadi Runtime 123 Minutes

4 Fame (2009)

Original: Fame (1980)

Close

As the political and social landscape of the U.S. evolved at a rapid rate, Fame was met with interest and outrage at its portrayal of young people.

Loosely based on the real performing arts high school, LaGuardia, in New York City, the 1980 Fame balanced music, performance, dancing, and the desire for celebrity with a raw depiction of the teenage experience. As the political and social landscape of the U.S. evolved at a rapid rate, Fame was met with interest and outrage at its portrayal of young people. However, it’s only grown in the estimation of viewers and critics as it’s aged. The same cannot be said for the remake that hit theaters in 2009.

The 2009 Fame came out at the worst possible time for film and television focusing on teen issues. In 1980, it was interesting and boundary-pushing to discuss identity, sexuality, and struggles with mental illness. These topics were more commonplace by 2009, but the media hadn’t yet reached the intensity and explicit depictions of teen life that exploded in the late 2010s and early 2020s. What resulted was a PG version of Fame that had none of the bite or discourse that made the original a remarkable work of cinema.

Fame
PG
Comedy
Documentary
Drama
Musical
Romance

Where to Watch

*Availability in US

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

Director Kevin Tancharoen Release Date September 23, 2009 Cast Kay Panabaker , Naturi Naughton , Kherington Payne , Megan Mullally , Bebe Neuwirth , Debbie Allen Runtime 102 minutes

3 Charlie And The Chocolate Factory (2005)

Original: Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (1971)

Close

Any remake of Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory that has someone other than Gene Wilder playing Willy Wonka is doomed to fail. The most recent origin story of the chocolatier, starring Timothée Chalamet, has come the closest to the magic of the original but still falls short of the first and best take on the story. Like any Roald Dahl story, Willy Wonka is a little off-putting and should occasionally make the audience a little uncomfortable. However, the 2005 movie directed by Tim Burton never gives the audience a break from the eerie atmosphere.

It wasn’t just Wilder’s inspired performance that made the 1971 iteration so definitive, as all parts of the movie came together to outlast any other version. Willy Wonka is remembered with the same nostalgia and cultural understanding as classics like The Wizard of Oz, and few can claim that they haven’t seen the film. Instead of using the magical elements as a means to discuss real topics, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was only interested in the aesthetics of the fantasy.

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
PG
Adventure
Comedy
Family
Fantasy

Where to Watch

*Availability in US

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

In this movie based on the Roald Dahl novel, Charlie Bucket’s life changes forever when he finds a Golden Ticket, allowing him to tour the famous Willy Wonka’s Chocolate Factory along with four other contest winners.

Director Tim Burton Release Date July 13, 2005 Cast Johnny Depp , Freddie Highmore , David Kelly , Helena Bonham Carter , Noah Taylor , Missi Pyle , James Fox , Deep Roy , Christopher Lee Runtime 115 minutes

2 The Mummy (2017)

Original: The Mummy (1999)

Close

Unfortunately, casting Tom Cruise in a movie is not a surefire way to make the project too big to fail. While Cruise has a fantastic box office draw, the reality of his 2017 The Mummy turning into yet another franchise for the star didn’t live up to its potential. The first film starring Brendan Fraser and Rachel Weisz has faced some criticism over its dated visual effects and off-color jokes. However, it has a realism and humanity that the cold detachment of the 2017 The Mummy lacks in every way.

The attempt to make this film’s version of the mummy terrifying and be taken as seriously as possible failed on all counts and lacked the humor and warmth of the original.

Parts of the 1999 film are scary and thrilling, but the movie never takes itself too seriously and is firmly rooted in the adventure genre, not pure action-thriller. Despite its enormous budget and high-profile stars, the gritty, slate gray palette of the 2017 The Mummy is boring from beginning to end. The attempt to make this film’s version of the mummy terrifying and be taken as seriously as possible failed on all counts and lost the humor and warmth of the original.

The Mummy (2017)
PG-13
Fantasy
Adventure
Action

Where to Watch

*Availability in US

• stream
• rent
• buy

Not available

Not available

Not available

Directed by Alex Kurtzman and starring Tom Cruise, The Mummy is a 2017 reboot of the cult classic Mummy franchise that originally starred Brenden Frasier. This time, the plot follows a U.S. Army Sergeant as he attempts to stop the mummy of Princess Ahmanet from summoning the Egyptian diety Set.

Release Date June 9, 2017 Cast Tom Cruise , Javier Botet , Annabelle Wallis , Marwan Kenzari , Courtney B. Vance , Russell Crowe , Jake Johnson , Sofia Boutella , Selva Rasalingam Runtime 1h 50m Budget 125–195 million

1 Point Break (2015)

Original: Point Break (1991)

Close

The original Point Break is one of the movies that defined Keanu Reeves’ career due to his amazing chemistry with co-star Patrick Swayze and the iconic nature of the project. It was completely different from other action movies coming out at the time and positioned the importance of Johnny and Bodhi’s relationship above all else. In some ways, Point Break was paid tribute to in the 2001 film The Fast and the Furious. It followed a similar format but changed essential elements that positioned the movie to spin off into an international franchise.

This is what made the 2015 Point Break so pointless and disappointing. It’s clear from the beginning that the filmmakers thought the essential part of the original movie’s plot was the action sequences, turning them up by focusing on extreme sports instead of surfing. Additionally, Point Break fell victim to the rampant issue of the 2010s when interesting stylistic choices were thrown out in favor of mass appeal and marketability. The result is a film that looks and feels flat throughout.

Point Break (2015)
PG-13
Action

A remake of the 1991 film, Point Break is an action crime-thriller that follows former extreme sports athlete Johnny Utah as he becomes an FBI agent. In the middle of a case that involves daredevil thieves stealing diamonds and millions of dollars, Utah is assigned the case after determining their targets are attempting to complete eight ordeals known as the Ozaki 8. Joining the group undercover, the line begins to slowly blur between his job and his love of the rush once more.

Director Ericson Core Release Date December 25, 2015 Writers Kurt Wimmer Cast Luke Bracey , Edgar Ramirez , Teresa Palmer , Ray Winstone Runtime 114 Minutes Budget $105 million

Expand

Source: https://www.lsu.edu.vn
Category: Entertainment